Microservices are getting increasingly adopted for rebuilds and new application development. As this becomes more commonplace, stakeholders are beginning to realize that testing is significantly less effective now than it used to be with traditional applications.
What is the Test Pyramid Approach?
The Test Pyramid approach to testing highlights the unit tests that focus on the individual functions and code of the application. This would represent the bulk of the test pyramid strategy, so on the pyramid, this goes at the very bottom, which is the largest section. After the unit tests, there are integration tests. Integration tests validate the interactions between two or more connected components. Contract tests are not usually a part of the test pyramid approach, but they can be included in the same section of the pyramid as the integration tests. Then comes the smallest section of the pyramid, the end-to-end tests or E2E tests. These tests focus on the output of the application workflows.
As one progresses towards the top of the pyramid, the cost and effort for developing & running the tests increases. This would explain why unit testing is the preferred system because it needs the least cost and effort to conduct.
Now this is the situation for traditional testing. What happens when one moves to the microservices architecture? Then, unit testing is no longer as effective since it won’t provide sufficient application coverage. Microservices applications would usually have much less code than traditional applications. They would also have more connected customers as well as providers. In a service-oriented architecture, consumer services initiate requests for services provided by external systems. For instance, a checkout service might invoke a payment service to process a transaction. Conversely, provider services are designed to receive and process these requests. Now, the payment service would receive the payment request, process the transaction, update its database, and subsequently send a response to the consumer service, indicating the status of the payment.
In the context of microservices architecture, integration tests assume greater significance than unit tests. This shift in prioritization is driven by the intricate dependencies and interactions between services. While unit tests are essential for verifying the correctness of individual components, integration tests are crucial for ensuring the seamless collaboration of these components within the overall system.
In addition to integration tests, end-to-end (E2E) tests play a vital role in validating the complete functionality of the system from the user’s perspective. By simulating real-world scenarios, E2E tests help identify issues that may arise due to interactions between different components.
To effectively implement this testing strategy, a “Test Honeycomb” approach can be adopted. In this model, integration tests form the central and largest component, while unit and E2E tests occupy smaller but equally important positions. This structure emphasizes the critical role of integration testing in ensuring the reliability and performance of the microservices architecture.
While contract testing is not explicitly mentioned in the Test Honeycomb, it is an essential practice that complements integration testing. By defining and enforcing contracts between services, contract testing helps to maintain compatibility and prevent integration issues as services evolve.
Integrated and E2E Testing Challenges
While integration and end-to-end tests offer comprehensive coverage of microservice interactions, they are not without their challenges. One significant limitation is their reliance on external resources and the state, which can make them more complex and time-consuming to execute.
Moreover, changes to a component’s interface, such as modifications to request or response payloads, can have cascading effects on other components that rely on those interfaces. Identifying and addressing these dependencies can be a complex task, especially in large-scale microservice architectures. To mitigate this risk, extensive integration testing is often required, involving a significant number of test cases.
While the exact number of integration points may vary depending on the specific architecture, it is essential to maintain a comprehensive list of dependencies and ensure compatibility across all components. As the application evolves, managing these dependencies becomes increasingly challenging, necessitating careful planning and execution.
To ensure the successful execution of integration and end-to-end tests, all components and their dependencies must be available and up-to-date. In microservice architectures, where multiple teams often work in parallel on different services, coordinating updates and ensuring compatibility can be a significant challenge. The need for comprehensive testing before deployment further complicates the process.
To address these challenges, a solution is required that can isolate components for testing, eliminating the dependency on external services. This would enable developers to confidently test their changes in a controlled environment before deploying them to production.
So, what does this tell us?
While unit testing remains a valuable practice, its traditional emphasis on testing strategies may not be the most effective approach for serverless architectures. In microservices architectures, the proliferation of interconnected components necessitates a shift towards integration and end-to-end testing.
However, these testing methods can be challenging to implement, as they often require the availability of all components and their dependencies. This can be particularly problematic in complex environments where multiple teams are working on different parts of the system.
To mitigate these challenges, contract testing emerges as a powerful technique. By defining and enforcing contracts between services, contract testing ensures that components can interact seamlessly, even as they evolve independently. This approach helps to reduce the need for extensive integration testing, improve testing efficiency, and accelerate development cycles.
To learn more about serverless, automated testing, and other DevOps tools & techniques, enroll for the best DevOps training and certification course and advance your career in the field of DevOps.
Learn DevOps with Cognixia
Enroll in Cognixia’s DevOps Training to strengthen your career. Take a step to boost your career opportunities and prospects. Get into our DevOps certification course that is hands-on, collaborative, and instructor-led. Cognixia is here to provide you with a great online learning experience, to assist you in expanding your knowledge through entertaining training sessions, and to add considerable value to your skillset in today’s competitive market. Individuals and the corporate workforce can both benefit from Cognixia’s online courses.
Regardless of your familiarity with IT technology and procedures, the DevOps Plus course gives a complete look at the discipline, covering all critical ideas, approaches, and tools. It covers the fundamentals of virtualization, its advantages, and the different virtualization tools that play a vital part in both learning & implementing the DevOps culture, starting with a core introduction to DevOps. You’ll also discover DevOps tools like Vagrant, Containerization, VCS, and Docker and Configuration Management using Chef, Puppet, SaltStack, and Ansible.
This DevOps course covers intermediate to advanced aspects. Get certified in DevOps and become acquainted with concepts such as the open-source monitoring tool Nagios, including its plugins, and its usage as a graphical user interface. The Advanced DevOps fundamentals and Docker container clustering leveraging Docker Swarm & Kubernetes in the CI/CD Pipeline Automation are thoroughly discussed.
Our online DevOps training covers the following concepts –
- Introduction to DevOps
- GIT: Version Control
- Maven
- Docker – Containers
- Puppet for configuration management
- Ansible
- Nagios: Monitoring
- Jenkins – Continuous Integration
- Docker Container Clustering using Docker Swarm
- Docker Container Clustering using Kubernetes
- Advanced DevOps (CI/CD Pipeline Automation)
Prerequisites
This course requires just a basic grasp of programming & software development. These requirements are helpful but not compulsory because this all-inclusive training is aimed at newcomers and experienced professionals.
